I am one of the poor souls who absolutely cannot abide Daylight Saving Time.
I’ve hated it ever since I was old enough to understand it.
Perhaps at one time it was useful.
The original intent of it was to save energy.
When it was standardized in the US in 1966, DST began on the last Sunday in April and ended on the last Sunday in October – 6 months total.
States are not required to observe DST.
Indeed, Hawaii and parts of Arizona do not, nor do Puerto Rico, the US Virgin Islands, or Guam.
The theory behind DST is that less energy will be used in the evening, because people will be outside.
However, by the time you factor in such things as changing climate patterns and more household appliances, it really saves nothing.
What DST actually does is make certain retailers more money.
Lobbyists have worked long and hard to extend DST, thus making their industries more lucrative.
The federal DST law was amended in 1986, adding a full month to DST.
It would now begin on the first Sunday in April rather than the last.
According to Michael Downing, author of Spring Forward: The Annual Madness of Daylight Saving Time, “This change was spurred by a large number of lobbies: golf and golf equipment, home improvement, the Hearth, Patio and Barbecue Association and the gas and fuel industries, which saw a potential boon to their sales.”
Then in 2005, along with a host of other issues, the Energy Policy Act changed DST yet again.
Clocks were set ahead one hour on the second Sunday of March instead of on the first Sunday of April.
Clocks were set back one hour on the first Sunday in November, rather than on the last Sunday of October.
Downing says that “the change from the end of October to early November was not driven by energy savings, but by the National Association of Convenience Stores (NACS), who wanted Halloween to occur during DST. It gave the children more time to trick or treat and eat more candy.”
There has been no definitive study done on whether or not DST actually saves energy since the 1970’s.
However, there is no doubt that DST makes certain retailers money.
As it stands currently, DST lasts for 8 months of the year – from March to November.
So if there are only 4 months of non-DST time, is that really ‘standard time’?
It’s questionable (and rather unlikely) that DST actually saves energy.
And in this day and age of global connectivity, it makes even less sense.
In the EU, DST or ‘Summer Time,’ begins on the last Sunday of March and ends on the last Sunday in October.
While the US (and thus, SL) changed clocks last night, it will be another 3 weeks before the EU does so.
Australia and NZ are opposite (as are their seasons).
DST will end on April 5, 2015, and they will set their clocks back one hour (and thus then be two hours off of SL time?).
DST will begin again for them on October 4, 2015, when they will ‘spring forward’ one hour.
It’s all so very confusing.
Who has to be where when?
Although perhaps there was a point to DST in the beginning, I think it is an idea which has outgrown its use.
The only people seeing benefits from it appear to be businesses.
There are some who might argue DST has it positives, but for me, they are sorely outweighed by the negatives (sorry, Nai).
Yes, I enjoy an hour more of daylight in the evenings.
However, I now have to get up in pitch dark, and end up using more energy in the mornings just to see where I am going.
My children head to school in the dark (a teenager behind the wheel in broad daylight is scary enough, much less pitch black).
Let me reiterate –
I hate, I absolutely loathe, DST.
Will it change?
Probably not, because I’m not a lobbyist with millions of dollars from major industries in my pocket.
Resistance is futile.
7 thoughts on “Resistance Is Futile”
Trust me, those extensions to DST made by the US “powers that be” make no sense at all up in the north here in Canada but we are forced to follow them for “business” reasons or as they like to say “to promote consistent economic and social interaction”. Since we have five times zones in Canada and manage to conduct economic and social interactions with that in mind amongst ourselves, being one hour out of sync with the US for a few extra weeks doesn’t seem that big a deal to me.
We have multiple time zones in the US as well, but I just don’t understand the need for DST. In addition, there are studies that show that DST is actually harming people’s health.
We are used to working around time differences these days, but DST just seems completely unnecessary. For anyone, not just the USA.
It makes things complicated for no good reason. But then, I suppose that’s the government for you. 🙂
I’m right there with you Kat. If we’re going to have DST, then we should at least be on par with the rest of the world. I’m sitting here grumping along and missing my hour of sleep. I’ll be up too late tonight and grumpy when I get up tomorrow. My SL world clock is confused and my watch is so confusing, that I just roll it through all the time zones until I find one from South America in the correct time zone and leave it on that instead of trying to figure out how to make my NYC time zone option be on DST….I still think it would be better for days to be longer in the winter when the sun sets so darned early, than in the summer when it’s just hotter! There endeth the rant…. 🙂
You can’t please everyone, I know that. But wouldn’t it just make more sense to just leave time alone? The different time zones make things confusing enough, without throwing more monkey wrenches into the works. If we’re going to be forced into DST, they could at least have the decency to start it on Sunday night, so everyone has an excuse to be late to work on Monday!!! 😛
Is everyone as grumpy when they get an extra hour in bed at the other end?
No, because we get our hour back. 😛
Amen and amen. DST Monday is one of my least favorite days of the year. And for what?
Comments are closed.